When people shop for a mortgage, they often focus on one thing: getting the lowest interest rate.
And while getting a good rate is important, there’s something else that deserves just as much attention: how your mortgage actually works when interest rates change.
This is particularly important when comparing a variable-rate mortgages (VRM) and an adjustable-rate mortgages (ARM).
They might sound like the same thing, but there’s a pretty significant difference between the 2. Depending on which one you choose, a change in interest rates could affect your monthly payments, how quickly you pay down your mortgage, and even how much interest you end up paying over time.
Let’s break it down.
1. Adjustable-rate mortgages (ARM): Your payment changes when rates do
With an adjustable-rate, your monthly payment moves up or down whenever your lender’s prime rate changes.
The advantage here is that your mortgage continues to follow its original amortization schedule. In other words, you’re still on track to pay off your mortgage within the same timeframe as you had anticipated to.
In an environment like today where the prime rate is projected to go up ,the downside is that your monthly payment increases when interest rates rise.
As an example, let’s say you have a $500,000 mortgage with a 25-year amortization and an initial interest rate of 3.43%.
Your monthly payment would be approximately $2,478.
If interest rates increased, here’s what that payment could look like:
- At 3.43%: $2,478/month
- At 4.43%: $2,748/month
- At 5.43%: $3,032/month
That’s roughly another $270 per month for every 1% increase in your interest rate.
The good news is that your mortgage stays on schedule. The bad news is that your monthly budget takes the hit. This can particularly be tough for first time home buyers to swallow, especially if you are cash tight.
2. Variable-rate mortgages (VRM): Your payment stays the same, but there’s a catch
With a fixed payment variable-rate, your monthly payment typically stays the same even when interest rates increase.
Instead of increasing your payment, the lender changes how much of that payment goes toward interest vs paying down principal.
Let’s use the same $500,000 mortgage with a $2,478 monthly payment.
When rates are low, a larger portion of your payment goes toward paying down your mortgage.
But as interest rates increase, more of that same $2,478 goes toward interest, leaving less money to reduce your mortgage balance.
Eventually, you could reach a point where almost your entire payment is going toward interest, referred to as the trigger rate. At that point, interest starts adding onto your mortgage balance, which actually starts going UP, not down.
3. Understanding the trigger rate and trigger point
If you have a fixed payment variable-rate mortgage, two terms you really need to understand are the trigger rate and trigger point.
Trigger rate
This is the interest rate at which your regular mortgage payment is no longer enough to cover the interest being charged, because 100% of it is already going to interest and rates are continuing to increase
In these cases, the unpaid interest gets added to your mortgage balance each month. This is called negative amortization. This starts pushing up your mortgage balance slowly, which increases the timeframe it takes to pay off your mortgage too(your amortization starts going up).
Trigger point
The trigger point is a separate threshold defined in your mortgage contract.
If your mortgage balance reaches the original mortgage amount you had gotten with the lender, your lender can require you to take action, because they can no longer tack on any more interest to the mortgage balance.
That could mean:
- Increasing your monthly mortgage payment to pay it down below the original mortgage amount.
- Making a lump-sum payment toward your mortgage.
Using our $500,000 example, with a starting rate of 3.43%, the estimated trigger rate is around 6.0%.
That’s approximately a 2.6 percentage-point increase from the starting rate.
The exact trigger rate and trigger point will depend on your lender and mortgage contract.
4. The hidden cost of keeping your payment low
One of the biggest misconceptions about variable-rate mortgages is that keeping the same monthly payment means you’re protected from rising interest rates.
When your payment doesn’t cover all the interest being charged, the unpaid interest can get added to your mortgage balance.
- Unpaid interest gets added to your mortgage.
- You start paying interest on that additional interest.
- Your mortgage payoff date gets pushed further out.
- When you renew, you may need to make higher payments or a lump-sum payment to get things back on track.
So while your monthly payment might look attractive today, the long-term cost could be significantly higher.
A lower payment upfront doesn’t necessarily mean a cheaper mortgage.
5. Not all mortgage rates are calculated the same way
Theres another important caveat when comparing variable rate mortgages; the mortgage interest compounding.
Even if two lenders offer you the exact same interest rate, the amount of interest you pay can differ depending on how frequently it’s compounded.
For example, consider a $500,000 mortgage at 4.50% with a 25-year amortization.
Over a five-year term, the example in our comparison shows:
- Semi-annually compounded: $105,024 in interest.
- Monthly compounded: $106,039 in interest.
That’s over $1,000 in additional interest despite having the same rate.
Some lenders also calculate interest based on your payment frequency. For example, certain lenders like RBC may compound interest weekly if you’re making weekly mortgage payments.
It’s worth asking how your lender calculates interest before signing your mortgage agreement.
6. Prime rates and mortgage penalties can vary between lenders
Another thing borrowers often overlook is that not every lender uses the same prime rate.
Lenders set their own mortgage prime rates, which means two mortgages advertised at prime minus 1% could actually have different interest rates.
For example:
- TD mortgage prime of 4.60% minus 1% = 3.60%.
- A lender with a prime rate of 4.45% minus 1% = 3.45%.
Mortgage penalties can also differ depending on how your lender calculates them.
Even when you’re looking at a three-month interest penalty, the calculation may be based on your actual contract rate or the lender’s prime rate.
On a $500,000 mortgage balance, for example:
- Three months of interest at 3.60% = approximately $4,500. (contract rate penalty)
- Three months of interest at 4.45% = approximately $5,560. ( prime rate penalty)
This is why looking at the advertised interest rate alone doesn’t tell you the whole story.
7. So, which mortgage should you choose?
There’s no universal answer. It really comes down to your financial situation, risk tolerance and how long you plan on keeping your mortgage.
Here’s how I’d look at it:
Variable-rate mortgage (VRM)
- Lower payments today.
- Your payment generally stays the same when rates increase.
- Less of your payment goes toward principal as rates rise.
- You could face negative amortization, a higher payment requirement or a lump-sum payment.
Adjustable-rate mortgage (ARM)
- Your mortgage stays on its original amortization schedule.
- Your payment increases when rates rise.
- You continue paying down your mortgage as scheduled.
- You need to be comfortable with fluctuations in your monthly budget.
Fixed-rate mortgage
Personally, if you’re looking for a predictable payment and want to avoid the uncertainty of rising variable rates, I’d lean toward a competitive fixed-rate mortgage.
You know what your payment will be throughout the term, making it much easier to budget.
The biggest consideration, however, is how long you plan on keeping the mortgage.
If you think there’s a good chance you’ll sell, refinance or break your mortgage within the next 3–5 years, make sure you understand the potential penalty.
Breaking a fixed mortgage early can come with a substantial penalty, depending on the lender and the terms of your contract.
Sometimes the lowest rate isn’t necessarily the best mortgage.
Final thoughts
When comparing mortgage rates, don’t just ask what the interest rate is.
Ask how your payment changes when rates increase, how interest is calculated, what happens when you reach your trigger rate, and what it would cost to break your mortgage early.
Two mortgages can have very similar rates but work completely differently behind the scenes.